Torrance's Label | Torrance's Description | Exemplars | Christology | Strength or Weakness |
unitarian | moves "up" from individuals to God | Harnack, Hick | Jesus is an example of how to worship | ebionite? |
existential | moves "down" in an encounter provoking our response | Bultmann, early Barth | Jesus is the revelation that confronts us | docetic? |
Trinitarian | shares in the Son's fellowships through the Spirit | Torrance | Jesus is the high priest who includes us in his own divine fellowship | incarnational |
Newbigin's Category (adapted) | My Description of the Type in Terms of Apostolicity | Israelite Precedent? | New Testament Exemplar | Liturgical Focus |
Protestant | the Church's practice of Scripture brings the apostolic gospel to the world | prophets, rabbis | Acts 1:8 | preaching, faithful response |
ethical / baptist | the community life of commissioned disciples is the primary witness to Christ's reign in the world | saints, sages | Acts 2:46-47, 4:32-35 | universal participation, organic fellowship |
Catholic / Orthodox | sacraments incorporate the world into the Church of the apostles' successors | monarchs, priests | Acts 8:17 | hierarchical liturgy, visible unity |
charismatic | the Spirit sanctifies and anoints apostles to revive churches and liberate the world | patriarchs, judges | Acts 10:44-48 | powerful liturgy, personal transformation |
My Label | My Description | Prooftext | Ecclesial Priorities | Eschatology |
assimilationist | the world absorbs the Christian community | Rev 3:1-6 | other narratives, gospels, missions, ends, and agents | futurist |
Constantinian | civil authorities legislate the millennial reign of Christ | Isa 60:10-12 | civil sponsorship, rulership, activism, transformation | postmillennial |
spiritualist | Holy Spirit calls individuals out of a godforsaken world | Rev 18:4-8 | conversion, piety, personal difference, social renunciation and withdrawal | premillennial |
developmental | new works of the Spirit change the Church as it interacts with the world | Acts 15 | receptivity to development and variety (e.g., Romanization, canonization, creedalization, Germanization, globalization) | inaugurated |
primitivist | the missionary community's shape is indifferent to its surroundings | Heb 13:8 | continuity with the past rather than responsivity to cultural context | realized |
proleptic | the Church is what it is becoming | Eph 4:11-16 | vision, continuity with the future, faithfulness, repentance in the face of failure | dialectical |
My Label and Unabashed Opinion | Political Strategy | Clapp's Label (or Mine), and Affinity |
Neo-constantinianism | seek vestiges of usefulness to society | "recapitulation" (close to assimilation) |
Paleo-constantinianism | try to reclaim lost civil power and authority | "retrenchment" (basically Constantinian) |
Hypo-constantinianism | withdraw into private spiritualism | "relinquishment" (spiritualist) |
Anti-constantinianism | concentrate on fighting the alliance | (reactionism) (close to primitivism) |
A-constantinianism | pursue the original politics of being Christ's Way | "radicalization" (proleptic?) |